Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) Review: A Charming Broadway Rom-Com
Original Broadway Cast of Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
This charming musical is a true love letter to New York City—filled with humor, heart, and the unexpected connections that can change your life. Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) follows two people on an adventure across Manhattan, discovering that sometimes you need a stranger to remind you how beautiful you are.
What Makes Two Strangers Special:
Intimate two-person musical that feels epic
Smart, fun, funny, and clever script
Beautiful exploration of vulnerability and independence
Inventive staging and creative lighting
A wonderfully structured story that sweeps you up
Our reviewers couldn't recommend this show enough. "We love this show. Love this. I would take my kids to. It doesn't really matter that they're five and seven. I thought it was so inventive and creative."
The highlight? The emotional connection and joy. "I have so much love in my heart right now and you can feel it through the audience. This is just like a well of goodness."
The show celebrates New York while exploring deeper themes. "This is a love poem to New York City from the outside that reminds us who the heck we are."
Your Family Guide to Two Strangers
Theatre for Family Audiences (TFA) Rating: Family Guided
Recommended Age: 12-13+
Conversation Starter: After
Marvelous Family Pick: ⭐ Yes
What Parents Need to Know
This is a romantic comedy best suited for teens and families. While younger kids can enjoy elements, the themes resonate most with older audiences.
Content to be aware of:
Some language (not extensive)
Adult themes and innuendo (handled with subtext)
References to relationships and intimacy
Themes about navigating new cities and independence
What Makes This Special for Families
"There are things that might fly over the younger kids, which is okay. And I think that there's many lovely things that the kids can like hold on to. Like there's very beautiful lighting. The music is so fun."
Great for families with:
Teenagers exploring independence and relationships
Kids interested in New York City
Families who appreciate smart romantic comedies
Those ready for conversations about vulnerability and connection
Conversations to Have After the Show
Topics to explore:
Navigating new cities and independence
Building relationships and vulnerability
Following your instincts
What it means to truly see and support someone
The Bottom Line
"I would definitely bring my nieces and nephews that are 12 and 13 and 14. Not every show is for a whole family audience. Bring your older kids and come to this show."
"Hopeful and it's positive and we need more of that. Good art, good feelings, good times. I would 100% bring my family. So, basically, we can't recommend it enough. Go, go, go, go, go, go."
